ISU The May Agency | Serving Southern Indiana for 3 Generations

The May Agency has been providing insurance expertise to central and southern Indiana for three generations and nearly 70 years. The May Insurance Agency was founded by Charles H “Bus” May in 1949. Bus started the insurance agency in Ellettsville, Indiana after returning from his service in World War II. Bus also owned a prosperous residential/commercial construction business and by 1967, he realized he needed help managing the insurance business. He called his son, Paul May, and asked him, “Would you like to give it a shot?” Paul decided to give it a try and found he enjoyed the insurance business. Shortly after starting in the insurance business, Paul was drafted and spent the next two years serving in the military. When he returned to Bloomington after his military service, the company opened a second office in Bloomington and eventually combined the two offices into one Bloomington office that has been located at the corner of 17th Street and Walnut Street since the late 1970s. Paul’s daughter, Sarah May, joined the company in 2002.

Charles H “Bus” May

Charles H “Bus” May

Paul May

Paul May

Sarah May

Sarah May

Original Agency 1960

May Insurance Agency, Ellettsville, IN, mid-1950’s

May Insurance Agency, Ellettsville, IN, mid-1950’s

Hudson Dealership

Hanson Building (current May Agency building), Bloomington, IN, late 1940’s

Hanson Building (current May Agency building), Bloomington, IN, late 1940’s

The May Agency, Bloomington, IN, mid-1980’s

ISU The May Agency, current

We are the trusted advisors for a multitude of individuals, families and businesses who seek to transfer their risk through insurance. No need is too great or too small. We help our customers determine their needs, understand their challenges, and then make informed decisions about the solutions for protecting their wealth and assets.

We offer Business, Home, Auto, Life, and Health coverage, a dedicated Claims Department to help you when you suffer a loss or a crisis. We genuinely care about you, your business, your family. We are here to help.

We are the One Responsible Source for all of your insurance needs.

We are proud to have earned the Reader’s Choice Award from our local community in the Herald Times newspaper fourteen times. We treat each other like family, and we were awarded by the Greater Bloomington Chamber of Commerce as the Family Friendly Business of the Year in 2011.

Our agents are recognized for their excellence in customer service, insurance knowledge, and stellar relationships with our clients and the company representatives. We have earned many awards, from Agency of the Year, to Outstanding Customer Service Insurance Agent of the Year, to Top 10 Professional Under 40.

Please contact us today to learn more about our solutions and find out about the package discounts available.

Insurance Services Unlimited (ISU) & Acrisure

ISU Member Agencies – 2018

The May Agency became ISU The May Agency in 1990. Insurance Services Unlimited (ISU) is a group of member insurance agencies that span the country from coast to coast. Headquartered in San Francisco, with over 100 agencies, ISU members have access to over 350 insurance carriers, giving members the ability to find coverage for the most unusual or difficult to write policies. ISU Insurance Agency Network is an organization exclusively for independent insurance agencies that offers a cohesive national database of insurance knowledge. The Power of Independence and the Strength of Unity allows ISU’s members to effectively solve your insurance and financial risk management problems, such as price, coverage, satisfactory claims settlements, security and peace of mind.

Acrisure Agency Partners – 2018

ISU The May Agency is also part of Acrisure, one of the top 10 insurance agencies in the United States. Headquartered in Michigan, the network of Acrisure Agency Partners are able to provide the local, personal level of service that you deserve with the added power of deep industry expertise available to each and every client. The concept of national reach + local presence is not just an ideal; it’s who and what Acrisure is.