To protect public health and safety, the ISU May Agency is implementing social distancing.
Please stay safe at home during this time and call or email for your insurance needs.
Please call us at 812-334-2400 or use our contact form.

Learn more below about how we can best serve you


ISU The May Agency is a full-service insurance agency with a focus on bringing value to our clients. We can assist with all of your insurance needs including Business, Home, Auto, Renters, Life, and Health. Our office is equipped with the latest technology and each of our knowledgeable insurance agents will take the time to explain your options and tailor a policy suited specifically for you.

We provide quality protection and superior customer service. As your local, independent agency, we have access to hundreds of insurance carriers, enabling our agents to effectively compare rates and coverage, ensuring our clients receive the quality protection and service they deserve.

Unlike many other home & auto insurance websites you may have come across, we will NEVER sell your information. Contact us to get a fast and accurate quote without any hassle.


Business insurance is made easy with the help from our experienced agents and advisors. From sole proprietors to companies with hundreds of employees, we have the expertise to get you the coverage you need.

Get A Quote Our Products

Home & Auto

Allow ISU The May Agency to help you obtain the best value for your home and auto insurance.

Get A Quote Our Products

Life & Health

Protect what is important to you with Life & Health Insurance from ISU The May Agency. Our experienced agents are here to help you make the best decisions.

Get A Quote Our Products

See What Our Customers Have to Say

Clay was the most responsive and helpful insurance agent I’ve ever had. Honest guy, straight shooter, and bend over backwards to help. Plus this agency (and Clay) has always consistently found me the lowest price for the same coverage (I know, I shopped around every 6 months!)

Tony K.

ISU The May Agency and Lisa Slone are top notch. Very good rates for my business needs and are very prompt to answer any questions you might have.

Kyle Winkler

I would definitely recommend ISU The May Agency. I am a lot more comfortable with the arrangement they provide in terms of being able to speak face-to-face with people.

Garth Thomas

I became a client of ISU The May Agency a few years ago, after a friend had switched from my same insurance company. She liked The May Agency so much better so I decided to make the switch as well. They not only saved me money by having lower rates, but they also really took the time to explain my coverage to me and made me feel very secure with them.

Robyn Fuller

I truly enjoy being a client of ISU The May Agency. The service there is second to none. They have always given me personal attention whenever I need them. I like that they have taken the time to get to know me, so we are at a personal level. They gave me their personal cell phone numbers and email addresses so I can always get in touch with them if I need to.

Kitt Eldridge

I would highly recommend ISU The May Agency to anyone who needs insurance. I get my home and auto coverage from them. Paul May is a really great and dedicated insurance agent. He would stand by your side in the pouring rain if you asked him to.

Hannah Marin

I have had a really great experience getting my insurance coverage by The May Agency. It is always easy to contact someone in the office if I need anything or have any questions. I also like that they are diligent in finding me the best coverage at the lowest cost.

Kendra Shillen

I like that if i have questions I can call my specific insurance agent and call him directly, versus having to call an 800 number and deal with someone I don’t know.

Natalie Ponty