Staff

Senior Management

Paul May

Paul May

Agency President

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2028

Direct Number: (812) 353-6499

Email: pmay@mayagency.com


Paul began his insurance career in 1967, becoming the second generation of the May family to work in the business.  The May Agency was founded by Paul’s father, Charles May, in 1949.  During Paul’s tenure, The May Agency has grown from a small, local agency to a large agency with regional and national clients.  Under Paul’s leadership, the agency has partnered with national organizations that have enabled The May Agency to access insurance carriers and expertise nationwide.

Father of three, grandfather of three, Paul and his wife Teresa enjoy spending time with their family and their Labrador, Louie.  Paul enjoys reading, travel, and spending time with friends.  A life-long car enthusiast who raced in his younger days, Paul continues to enjoy beautiful cars.

Lisa Slone

Lisa Slone

Agency Vice President / Commercial Lines Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2049

Direct Number: (812) 353-6481

Email: lslone@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 2001

Specialty: Business


Lisa began her insurance career in 2001 while working towards her Bachelor’s Degree from Indiana University. She has been with ISU The May Agency since 2009 and is the Vice President of the Agency. She works with Commercial Insurance clients as well as day-to-day responsibilities for maintaining the agency. When not in the office, Lisa enjoys spending time with her husband, Jim and their two children, Tanner and Kendall. “We love to travel as a family especially if it involves a beach and warm weather”.

Personal Lines

Lisa Hutsell

Lisa Hutsell

Personal Lines Manager

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2042

Direct Number: (812) 353-6488

Email: lhutsell@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 2003

Specialty: Home & Auto


Lisa has been with ISU The May Agency since March 2014, but has been in the insurance industry since 2003. She has worked for other agencies and also has had her own agency in Georgia. She moved here from Georgia when her father & Mother-in-law became ill, whom since have passed away. Now Lisa, her husband and 4 dogs, Cosmo & Daisy May, Wee Willie and & Georgie live in the family home. Lisa’s husband just retired as head wrestling coach at Bloomington North High School. Their goal is to be spending a week or so of the winter in Florida now that Lisa’s husband is no longer coaching during the winter.

Kathy Wilson

Kathy Wilson

Personal Lines Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2013

Direct Number: (812) 353-6482

Email: kwilson@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1984


Starting in high school, she established her insurance education in a local independent agency and obtained her property and casualty license. Later she obtained her Certified Insurance Counselor designation in order to provide the best service to her customers. Kathy is a lifelong resident of Bloomington and spending time with family is highly important and treasured. In her spare time, Kathy enjoys flower arranging, boating at Lake Monroe and exploring the many beautiful roadways of Southern Indiana along with her husband in their classic auto.

Clay Peterson

Clay Peterson

Personal Lines / Commercial Lines Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2033

Direct Number: (812) 353-6487

Email: cpeterson@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1994

Specialty: Home & Auto


Clay joined the agency in 2014 with over 20 years of experience as an agent in Bloomington. This father of three loves to spend time with his wife and children, work in the yard and watch baseball.

Commercial Lines

Clay Peterson

Clay Peterson

Personal Lines / Commercial Lines Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2033

Direct Number: (812) 353-6487

Email: cpeterson@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1994

Specialty: Home & Auto


Clay joined the agency in 2014 with over 20 years of experience as an agent in Bloomington. This father of three loves to spend time with his wife and children, work in the yard and watch baseball.

Joyce Riggs

Joyce Riggs

Commercial Lines Manager

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2031

Direct Number: (812) 353-6497

Email: jriggs@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1986


Joyce began her insurance career at Indiana Insurance in Personal Lines and then a claims secretary for 5 years. She has been with ISU The May Agency since 1986. She loves working with customers and becoming great friends with them. She is married and has three children and seven grandchildren. In her spare time, she enjoys gardening and spending time with family.

Allison England

Allison England

Commercial Lines Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2020

Direct Number: (812) 353-6491

Email: aengland@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 2011

Specialty: Business


Allison initiated her insurance career as a Customer Service Agent at Liberty Mutual Insurance. She migrated to ISU The May Agency in 2011. Allison enjoys paper crafting, reading, and baking. Allison and her husband Tim like to spend time fishing, and playing with their German Shepherd, Gunner.

Life & Health

Sabrina Saylor

Sabrina Saylor

Life & Health Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2017

Direct Number: (812) 353-6495

Email: ssaylor@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 2009

Specialty: Life & Health


Sabrina Saylor began her career in insurance as a Life & Health Insurance Agent in 2009 and has been with ISU The May Agency since 2010. Since 2009, she has also worked at Wildcare Inc., a local wildlife rehabilitation center. At Wildcare, Inc, she serves as the The Animal Care & Educational Outreach Coordinator, Licensed Wildlife Rehabber, as well as their Fox, Coyote, and Bobcat Team Leader. In her free time she enjoys spending time with her family and four dogs, she likes to hike, horseback ride, camp, baking, watching the Indianapolis colts and of riding her motorcycle.

Cheryl Terry

Cheryl Terry

Life & Health Account Executive

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2044

Direct Number: (812) 353-6480

Email: cterry@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1992


Cheryl has been with the Agency since 1992 as a Health and Life Agent. She is a member of the Association of Health Underwriters. Cheryl is an Indiana State University graduate with an Associate’s Degree in Business. She enjoys traveling and has been on trips to Honduras, South Africa, Mexico and Israel. She enjoys her family including vacationing with them and Sunday dinners. Cheryl is the mother of four and grandmother to thirteen. She enjoys cooking, baking, reading, attending IU games, and bike riding.

General Staff

Sarah May

Sarah May

Advertising/Marketing Manager, Accounts Payable

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2015

Direct Number: (812) 353-6486

Email: smay@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 2002


Sarah received a Bachelor of Science in Public Affairs from Indiana University in 1993 and a Master of Science in Environmental Science from Indiana University in 1997. Sarah worked as an environmental consultant for almost 15 years, conducting environmental assessments in over 40 states. She joined ISU May Agency on a part time basis in 2002. The May Agency was founded by Sarah’s grandfather, Charles May, in 1949 and she is the third generation from the May family to work in the business. Mother of one, Sarah is a troop leader for her daughter’s Girl Scout troop and is an advocate for Cystic Fibrosis research. She loves spending time outdoors, reading, gardening, cats, and traveling with her family.

Chris LaRoche

Chris LaRoche

Agency Claims Manager

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2043

Direct Number: (812) 353-6492

Email: claroche@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1996


Chris joined ISU The May Agency in October 1996. Chris handles all claims for ISU The May Agency clients. In her spare time she enjoys time with friends and family and loves to travel. She likes to cook and experiment with new recipes and is no stranger to the kitchen.

Karen Pierce

Karen Pierce

Receptionist

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2010

Direct Number: (812) 334-2400

Email: recept@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 2015


Karen joined ISU The May Agency in March 2015. Karen had two prior years of insurance experience prior to our agency. Born and raised in Bloomington, Karen has two children and nine grandchildren. Outside of the office, Karen enjoys spending time with family, caring for her pets, cooking/baking, and exercise.

Regina Haverly

Regina Haverly

Accounts Receivable / Accounting

Office Number: (812) 334-2400 Ext. 2037

Direct Number: (812) 353-6498

Email: rhaverly@mayagency.com


Insurance industry since 1974


Regina has worked in independent insurance agencies since 1974 providing service to our clients beginning with personal lines and then large commercial account customers. After spending several years boating, motorcycling and traveling in her motorhome, it is fun being a grandmother. One of her favorite things to do is being a grandma to 13 grandchildren.